This is a comment on the article Linux not ready for the desktop by Asa Dotzler. Unfortunately, I’d crafted this great comment and then found that the comments had closed on the article! Hey Asa, speaking of user friendly, your blog shouldn’t have a comment submission form available if the comments are closed!
Asa,
Great writing, I hope that lots of Linux techies listen up. I definitely agree with the points on migration and stability.
On migration, I think that a lot of users trying out Linux don’t give it enough of a chance because their settings, mail, bookmarks, etc aren’t in the system. They install it, logon and then say “what do I do now?”.
With stability, this is definitely a big issue and source of confusion for new Linux users. The whole API stability thing does introduce a lack of confidence in the general public regarding Linux. They hear the stories, experience something similar themselves, and then are quick to write it off. Some work in this area to improve user experience would go a long way.
I think that I might have to disagree slightly with the other points simplicity and comfort.
In regards to simplicity, my wife uses Linux as her OS, and has done so for a number of years. She knows nothing about Linux, and admitedly I administer and support the system for her, but she can get around on a gnome desktop just fine. She doesn’t seem to find any further trouble than using a Windows system.
I also think that comfort is not so much a big issue. Users tend to pick up differences like this with no big problems.
Maybe there needs to be a desktopfest organised? To help all those Linux keen users to get the most out of their systems. Just like the installfests helped thousands of users navigate the once “dangerous” Linux install process.
And, haven’t installs come a long way? Let’s hope that the desktop is the next item of focus for Linux developers.